Wednesday, January 28, 2009

the business

Quick side note: At one point during the lecture Prof. Mike Press gave on Tuesday I thought to myself "right now he kind of reminds me of Q-Tip from A Tribe Called Quest, who had the insight to rap 'industry rule #4080, record company people are shady'". If you are a fan, you may know what I mean. Q-Tip was able to be both industry-member and critical observer at the same time. Mike Press seems to be the same way.

Among the many tips he offered on carrying out a research project, two really stuck out in my mind: work with the best people and work with other specialists.

Obviously both are cut from the same cloth, and I am aware of why they struck a chord with me: I can't stand working alone. This has the potential to be a problem, as our research projects are, almost by default, solo adventures. While we will all have the privilege of a mentor, it seems as if everybody is gearing up to work by themselves.

This both scares and confuses me. Why should I work alone? I will almost certainly always be working in groups in any endeavor that I take on after the research project concludes—why should I practice working alone?

There is also the slightly related problem—where the hell do I want to carry out my project (don't worry, we'll get back to working alone in a second)? Since my research involves understanding what makes a city bike-friendly, I can conceivably carry it out in any bike-friendly city on planet Earth. When I inform people of this dilemma, they usually offer one, or both, of the following responses:

1) This is your chance to live anywhere for 3 months—take advantage of it.
2) What a good problem to have. I wish I was a student of Design Ethnography at the University of Dundee. (I made that last sentence up)

While I can respect both answers, I think that they are a bit misguided. We are told on a regular basis that the most important thing is this life is to make ourselves happy. Can I really be happy living by myself, away from the people that I need most in my life, even if it is in a location that offers cold cerveza and beautiful landscapes at the end of each day?

I don't think I can. As independent as I like to consider myself, I can't live without the support network of friends and family that I have established (and I'm sorry, but Facebook just doesn't do it for me). One of my greatest fears is finishing a day and not having any person (in physical form) to share a meal or beer with. Perhaps I am just not interesting enough to survive on my own.

So here is the tie in to working solo: it is in my established network places (New England and NYC) that I would be able to work with the best people (that I know) and specialists (again, that I know). There are people there that could supplement my work—even if we are not directly working together—to an astonishing degree. Also, let's not forget that I have actual bike-riding experience in both areas, which can't hurt.

Shouldn't this close the deal for me? Haven't I answered my own question and solved this problem once and for all? You would think so. But, for some reason, I am keeping myself on the fence.

Maybe I just like the thought of living in Barcelona or Amsterdam for three months.

Tuesday, January 27, 2009

hello. and a bit about ethnography.

What is ethnography?

Although I happen to be in a master's course in that very realm, I am still a bit unsure of what it all means. Back to this in a minute though.

A week ago, we were privileged enough to spend lunch with Richard Harper, a user researcher at Microsoft. Many things are worth noting.

1. I was expecting somebody who was convinced that technology is the best thing since peanut butter, and was completely wrong. He gets it. Mr. Harper understands that most humans do not care about the speed of the bluetooth connection (or what the hell bluetooth actually is) of their phone—they just want to be able to share things with their friends and family. Or in his words, us humans "just want to play". Word.

2. He enjoyed (even though he didn't come out and say it) the lame mustache I had grown during vacation.

3. He once was an ethnographer for Arthur Anderson, the now-defunct accounting firm, and lived to tell about it.

Back to the definition. I often think of ethnography as "understanding people", which I still think to be true, but a bit limited in scope. Now I am under the impression that ethnography is all about understanding life, which consequently involves humans.

Yesterday we spent the day in Edinburgh on an ethnography assignment to find "traces of human activity", such as people leaving behind rubbish or notes, among other examples. While wandering around the city, I was obsessed with the actual traces: the coffee cups, people using walls as seats, etc. It only occurred to me as I was inhaling some panini at a local cafe that I was missing the point. Instead of understanding the traces, I should try to understand the life of Edinburghers. This realization allowed me to see the bigger picture for the rest of the day, and I believe it enhanced the results.

So what does this all mean? I'm not really sure. Perhaps that focusing too much on a single activity, even though it is being performed by a human, is a cheap excuse for ethnography. Maybe it means that walking around like outsiders with cameras and notebooks may look like ethnography, but can easily just be misguided tourism. It is like looking at one corner of the fishbowl without realizing that there is an entire tank we are forgetting about.

Of course all of this could be wrong, although it sure doesn't feel like it.

It seems that a problem with observation is that it is just a single snapshot of somebody's existence. It would be easy for Richard Harper to watch a human utilizing the bluetooth capability of a gizmo and saying "humans like bluetooth-y bells and whistles", instead of realizing that the human is using bluetooth to capture a quote from Anchorman to send to his or her friends.

This appears to be a simple concept when reading it in blog form. But when in the field, it can be very tough to keep this perspective.

By the way, happy year of the ox.